Dining

Casual Dining in Islamorada

Islamorada’s favorite gathering spots for dining indoors and out, our hotels' restaurants and bars draw locals and guests for beautifully prepared cuisine that’s anchored in the traditions of Key West. Whether your tastes are simple or sophisticated, trust our culinary team to create a memorable experience in which fresh seafood – the cornerstone of the Islamorada dining – plays a starring role.

Postcard Inn

Postcard Inn

Savor the birthplace of the original Rum Runner cocktail at the Holiday Isle Tiki Bar, sample fresh island seafood at the Raw Bar, and enjoy authentic, imaginative Tuscan flavors at Ciao Hound.

For more information on our menu and hours, please visit the Postcard Inn Holiday Isle website below.

Pelican Cove

Pelican Cove

Stake a spot at Wild & Lime, Pelican Cove’s shady outdoor eatery for tropical drinks, small plates and snacks, including conch ceviche, fish tacos, and smoked fish dip.

For more information on our menu and hours, please visit the Pelican Cove website below.

Amara Cay

Amara Cay

Enjoy cool tropical cocktails, fish tacos and Key Lime pie poolside at Sparrows Rum Bar, as well as delicious breakfasts and dinners with an Italian-meets-Keys twist at Oltremare Ristorante.

For more information on our menu and hours, please visit the Amara Cay website below.